2013: First Team: Kyle McLain (3B), Eddie Nogay (P), Ronny Peirish (C), Josh Staniscia (RF). Second Team: Scott Liller (2B), D.J. Michalski (1B), Brian O'Neill (P). Honorable Mention: Derek McIlvaine (LF), Tyler Schultz (1B/C).
2012: First Team: Aaron Klinec (SS), Kyle McLain (3B), Josh Staniscia (OF), Dave Trushel (P). Second Team: Ronny Peirish (C), Scott Liller (2B), Eddie Nogay (P). Honorable Mention: Brian Szabo (OF), Randy Risch (P), Brian O'Neill (P).
2011: First Team: Joe Bogdewiecz (SS), Josh Staniscia (OF). Second Team: Andy Trettel (OF), Jordan Zivoder (P), Pat Kennedy (P). Honorable Mention: Eddie Nogay.
2010: First Team: Frank Quirin (1B), Mike Kennedy (3B), Joe Bogdewiecz (SS), Jim Pasquine (OF), Neil Pascarella (OF), Pat Kennedy (P). Second Team: Mark Thomchick (C), Andy Trettel (OF), Dave Trushel (P).
2009: First Team: Mark Thomchick (C), Joe Bogdewiecz (SS), Jim Pasquine (UT), Dave Trushel (P). Second Team: Frank Quirin (1B), Neil Pascarella (OF), Pat Kennedy (P).
2008: First Team: Jim Pasquine (3B), Ian Poole (P). Second Team: Joe Bogdewiecz (SS), Justin Benson (OF).
2007: First Team: Sam Mann (P/1B), Chris Varacallo (2B), Shawn Pfeil (3B), Nick Fiorelli (SS), John Astfalk (P). Second Team: Ian Poole (P), Ron Mitko (UT).
2006: First Team: Sam Mann (P/1B), Chris Varacallo (2B), Shawn Pfeil (3B), Matt Pellis (OF), Ian Poole (P). Second Team: Warren Stowe (C), Ron Mitko (OF), John Astfalk (P), Mike Trumpower (P).
2005: First Team: Shawn Pfeil (3B), Justin Benson (OF), Ron Mitko (OF), Sam Mann (P), Mike Trumpower (P). Second Team: Chris Varacallo (2B), Nick Fiorelli (SS).
2004: First Team: Sam Mann (P), Mike Trumpower (P). Second Team: Chris Varacallo (2B), Brett Glass (OF).
2003: First Team: B.J. Swartzlander (OF).
2002: First Team: B.J. Swartzlander (OF). Second Team: Frank Pilato (C), Jason Cramer (SS), Brent Rockwell (OF).
1997: First Team: J.R. Hall (P), Kip Kuzior (C), Todd Curtin (1B), Tim Agugla (OF). Second Team: Bill Olivani (2B), Steve Castor (SS).
1996: First Team: Tony DiGiandomenico (C), Chris Hega (OF). Second Team: Todd Curtin (1B), Brad O'Malley (P/SS), George Lewis (3B).
1995: First Team: John Lucchino (OF). Second Team: Larry Nishnick (OF), Todd Curtin (1B), Keith Porrzywinski (P/SS), Tony DiGiandomenico (C).
1991: First Team: Todd Henry, Dan Luko, Doug Cappell, Mike Whitehead, Mark Kovaly, Larry Pitts. Second Team: Chris Babirad, Terry Doughty.
1990: First Team: Boyd Wass (P), Terry Doughty (C), Todd Henry (1B), Mike Whitehead (3B), Larry Pitts (OF). Second Team: Mark Kovaly (SS), Ron Baily (OF). Honorable Mention: John Moses (2B), Ian Davis (P).
1987: First Team: Pat Aigner (C), Ralph Ritenour (P). Honorable Mention: John Moses (2B), Chris Berger (1B).
1985: First Team: John Salvitti (OF), Mike Saverse (SS).
1984: First Team: Mike Saverse (SS).
1982: First Team: Jeff Virgin (C). Honorable Mention: Lou Falbo.
1981: First Team: Max Regula (OF). Honorable Mention: Rick Roth (3B).
1978: Tim Boal (1B), Ken Klein (OF)
1977: Rick Pinelli (P). Honorable Mention: Paul Gelles (3B).
1976: Dave Fuhrer (OF).
1975: Tim Boal (1B). Honorable Mention: Dave Fuhrer (OF).
1973: Clair McCloy (OF).
1972: Jerry Palmer (3B), Clair McCloy (OF), Bill Hartman (P/1B).
1971: Dale McGar (SS), Clair McCloy (OF), Bill Hartman (P). Honorable Mention: Jerry Palmer (3B).
1969: Chuck Hergenroder (C), Bob Pigozzi (OF), Dick Mason (P). Honorable Mention: Jack Houser (IF), Mark Swayne (IF).
1968: Paul Aversano (OF), Jack Houser (3B).
1966: James Sitter (P), Donald Smith (3B).
1960: Robert Bowser (3B), William Hayes (OF).
1959: George Bailey, Ronald Pellegrini