2012: First Team: Ty Wildey (OL), Alex Baroffio (WR), Tim McNerney (RB), Ian Hennessy (LB), Nathan Melhorn (DB), Eric Eberle (PK). Second Team: Andrew Pingitore (OL), Dion Wiegand (RB), John Watts (DL), B.J. Monacelli (DB). Honorable Mention: Mike Mastellino (OL), Hunter Creel (WR), Matt Bliss (QB), Jon Lowery (DL), John Hunter (LB), DeAndre Simmons (LB), Zach DeCicco (DB).
2011: First Team: Gary Flavion (OL), Alex Baroffio (WR), Neil Sorice (LB), Nathan Melhorn (DB). Second Team: Justin Cole (OL), Matt Bliss (QB), Tim McNerney (RB), Frank Gigler (DL). Honorable Mention: Hunter Creel (WR), Adam Dominick (WR), Gavin Donathan (DL), Mitch Rose (LB),
2010: First Team: Gary Flavion (OL), Jordan Roycroft (WR), Craig Sedunov (DB), Joe Kelly (P). Second Team: Adam Zampatti (OL), Gino Rometo (QB), Tim McNerney (RB), Frank Gigler (DL), Andy McGill (DL), Neil Sorice (LB), Matthew Gal (DB).
2009: First Team: Craig Besong (WR), Kirk Fulton (OL), Jacob Bloomhuff (DL), Mitch Erdely (DB), Nathan Harmotto (DB), Craig Sedunov (DB), Joe Kelly (P). Second Team: Brandon Bovina (DL), Adam Zampatti (OL), Gary Flavion (OL).
2008: First Team: Bobby Swallow (QB), Dave Bucar (OL), Matt Houy (OL), Craig Besong (WR), Curt Jones (RB), Jacob Bloomhuff (DL), Nathan Harmotto (DB), Craig Sedunov (DB). Second Team: Kirk Fulton (OL), David Ravida (WR), David Gitlitz (LB).
2007: First Team: Bobby Swallow (QB), Dave Bucar (OL), Matt Houy (OL), Tom McCafferty (WR), David Gitlitz (LB), Kevin Mathews (AP). Second Team: Adam Shallcross (OL), Brendan O’Mahony (FB), David Ravida (WR), Curt Jones (RB), Jacob Bloomhuff (DL), Chris Kessler (DB), Ryan Mullen (DB).
2006: First Team: Bobby Swallow (QB), Ryan Mendel (RB), Chris Hickey (OL), Chris Teter (OL), Dan Brodland (DL), Aaron Bane (LB), Nick Cherish (DB), Kyle Sidebotham (PK). Second Team: Matt Sutphen (DL), Cory Walsh (DB), Kevin Mathews (KR).
2005: First Team: Chris Edwards, QB, Jon Miller, WR, Aaron Krepps, HB/RET, Chris Hickey, OL, Kyle Sidebotham, PK, Mike Sklarsky, LB, Mike Wilmus, DB. Second Team: R.J. Zitzelsberger, RB, Chris Teter, OL, Nick Cherish, DB
2004: First Team: Chris Edwards, QB, Jacob Shields, WR, Aaron Krepps, WR/RET, Chris Teter, OL, Rocco Nori, DL, Andy Shook, LB, Frank Pilato, DB, Nick Cherish, DB. Second Team: R.J. Zitzelsberger, RB, Kyle Sidebotham, PK, Kyle Hamilton, OL, Eric Field, LB, Mike Wilmus, DB.
2003: First Team: Bob Jazwinski, OL, Josh King, DL, Eric Field, LB, Frank Pilato, DB, Aaron Krepps, RET. Second Team: Mike Virgin, WR, Kyle Sidebotham, PK, Jonathan Herbert, DB.
2002: First Team: Joey Nichols, RB, Luke Ravenstahl, K, Bob Jazwinski, OL, Adam Newhouse, OL, Mike Virgin, WR, Roger Snyder, KR, Tim Hawkins, DB, Ben Hays, DB, Jon Betz, DL, Eric Field, LB. Second Team: Chris Bluemle, OL, Brian Dawson, QB, Todd Fry, WR, Tom Paff, TE, B.J. Swartzlander, LB, Jonathan Herbert, DB, Josh King, OL.
2001: First Team: Chad Adams, DB, Jon Herbert, DB, Chuck Benedict, DL, Greg Simatic, DL, Matt Dietz, LB, B.J. Swartzlander, LB, Brian Dawson, QB, Joey Nichols, RB, Todd Fry, WR, Geno Vacca, OL, Luke Ravenstahl, PK. Second Team: Andre Barnabei, DL, Ben Hays, DB, Jon Pons, RB, Dave Armitage, WR, Adam Newhouse, C, Andy Cooper, OL.
2000: First Team: Chad Adams, DB, Dave Armitage, WR, Chuck Benedict, DL, Nick Curinga, LB, Brian Dawson, QB, Matt Dietz, LB, Jason Hazelwood, DL, Jason Matusik, OL, Luke Ravenstahl, K, Ryan Silvis, WR, T.J. Srsic, OL. Second Team: R.J. Dreucci, OL, Jonathan Herbert, DB, Chris Mosely, RB, Joey Nichols, RB, Greg Simatic, DL.
1999: First Team: Dave Armitage, WR, Eugene Crosby, C, Nick Curinga, LB, Brian Dawson, QB, Owen George, DB, Jonathan Kralic, K, Todd Matijevich, TE, Jason Matusik, OL, Rob Phillips, OL, Ryan Silvis, WR, Les Strader, DL. Second Team: Dave Bigger, LB, Terry Dunbar, DL, Jeff Jeffers, DB, Joey Nichols, RB, Jon Pons, RB, T.J. Srsic, OL, Dave Steinbach, DB.
1998: First Team: Jason Matusik, OL, Ryan Silvis, WR, Brad O’Malley, QB, Terry Dunbar, DL, Kevin O’Malley, LB, Owen George, DB. Second Team: Eugene Crosby, C, Rob Phillips, OL, Matt Blodgett, TE, Dave Armitage, WR, Jason Barr, RB, Steve Speca, DB, Jon Kralic, K.
1997: First Team: Garret Dorn, C, Jeremy Fisher, LC, Brian Matijevich, TE, D.J. Valente, DL, Harry Silvis, LB, Kevin O’Malley, LB, Steve Speca, LB. Second Team: Sean Fisher, OL, Jason Barr, RB, Rahmaire Brooks, DL, Tony Foster, DL, Mike Vaughn, DB.
1996: First Team: Garret Dorn, C, Ronald Bodnar, TE, Jason Baer, QB, Andre Crosby, OT, Dwayne Poole, WR, Jake Williams, RB, Dan Primrose, DT, Doug Sleva, LB, Darren Moul, SS, Mike Evans, PK, Brian Plichta, P. Second Team: Chris Jones, OL, Jeremy Fisher, OL, D.J. Valente, DE, Harry Silvis, LB, Kevin O’Malley, LB, Sam Willis, DB.
1995: First Team: Jim Babirad, DB, Jason Baer, QB, Chris Begley, WR, Mike Evan, PK, Robert Hayes, CB, Mike Jones, OG, Tim McGarvey, TE, Keith Miller, RB, Tim Murdoch, LB, Brian O’Malley, LB, Chris O’Neill, DE, Dan Primrose, DT, Tim Ray, OG/C, Lane Turturice, OG, Darin Whitesel, P. Second Team: Jeremy Fisher, OL, Erik Franklin, LB, Darrin Hicks, G/T, Darren Moul, DB, D.J. Valente, DE.
1994: First Team: Lou Brungard, C, Mike Jones, OG, Darrin Hicks, OL, Tim McGarvey, TE, Chris Begley, WR, Jake Williams, RB, Jason Baer, QB, Mike Evan, PK, Matt Szczypinski, DL, Dan Primrose, DT, Mike Brooder, DL, Brian O’Malley, LB, Taj Lewis, DB, Ian Wagner, DB, Darin Whitesel, P. Second Team: Lane Turturice, OL, Mike Speca, WR, Ramont Small, RB, Chris O’Neill, DE, Erik Franklin, LB, Tim Murdoch, LB, Robert Hayes, CB.
1993: First Team: Mike Speca, WR, Jake Williams, RB, Jason Moore, OL, John Mueller, OL, Lou Brungard, C, Chip McCarthey, DB, Shawn McGee, LB, Jeff Zaminski, LB, M. Szczypinski, DL, Darin Whitesel, P. Second Team: J. Baer, QB, J.J. Jaronsinski, TE, M. Jones, OG, Cory Zahradnik, OL, Mike Evan, K, Ian Wagner, DB, Taj Lewis, DB, Mike Brooder, DL, Eric Tarpley, DL, Ray Cross, DL, Tom Behr, DL, Derry Quattrone, LB, Mike Crawford, DB.
1992: First Team: Chris Babirad, RB, Tony Denuzzio, C, Dave Fields, TE, Kevin Pintar, OB, Todd, Pivnick, OT, Mike Speca, WR, Scott Lautner, K, John Engelmohr, DT, Eric Tola, LB, Shawn Pendergast, LB, Rickey Williams, DB, Mike Crawford, DB. Second Team: Jason Moore, OL, John Mueller, OL, Boyd Wass, FB, Bob Strope, QB, Eric Tarpley, DT, Ray Cross, DE, Shawn McGee, LB, Matt DeBoer, DB.
1991: First Team: Chris Babirad, RB, Larry Pitts, FL, Bill Craig, TE, Tony Denuzzio, C, Todd Pivnick, OL, Kevin Pintar, OL, John Engelmohr, DT, Shawn McGee, LB, Eric Tola, LB, Gilbert Floyd, DB, Scott Lautner, K. Second Team: Bob Strope, QB, Jason Moore, OL, Tim Johnson, LB, Kevin Fullard, DB.
1990: First Team: Bob Strope, QB, Chris Babirad, RB, Larry Pitts, RB, Jeff Johnson, WR, Bill Craig, TE, Mike Koffler, OL, Scott Lautner, K, S. Swentkowsky, DL, Gary Galuska, LB, George Kidwell, LB, Frank Mysza, LB, Dave Conn, DB, Gilbert Floyd, DB. Second Team: Tony Denuzzio, C, Walter Lober, OL, Todd Pivnick, OL, John Engelmohr, DT, Kevin Fullard, DB.
1989: First Team: Mike Koffler, OT, Scott Lautner, K, James Sevcik, OT, Dave Conn, DB, Jeff Koman, TE, S. Swentkowski, DL, Gary Galuska, LB. Second Team: Rick France, FB, John Kelly, C, Ken Jones, OT, Frank Mysza, DE, Gilbert Floyd, DB, Nick Como, DB.
1988: First Team: Pat Aigner, QB, Chris Fullard, LB, John Kelly, C, Mark Kern, DE, Voltaire Meade, OG.
1987: First Team: Mark Kern, DT, Kirk Lago, LB, Voltaire Meade, OG, Jim Meyer, LB, A.J. Pagano, RB, A. Ruttenberg, WR, John Snyder, OT, Arnold Tarpley, DB. Second Team: Pat Aigner, QB, Rick France, RB, John Ivory, K, Paul Livingston, DB, Andy Pacak, TE, Jim Sevcik, NG, Matt Walsh, OT.
1986: First Team: Ted Bell, P, Jim Greaves, WR, Shiloh Icenhour, DB, Mark Kern, DT, Brian Martin, LB, J. McArdle, DB, G. McKenna, TE, Jim Meyer, LB, A.J. Pagano, RB, Rich Riotto, QB, J. Savage, NG, John Snyder, OT. Second Team: M. Walsh, OT, V. Meade, OG, Ted Bell, K, Pat Herr, DB.
1985: First Team: Eugene Berkowitz, OG, Steve Gulakowski, DB, Brian Martin, LB, George McKenna, TE, Jim Meyer, LB, A.J. Pagano, RB, J. Savage, NG, M. Walsh, OT, Orlando Williams, DT. Second Team: J. Greaves, WR, B.J. Walters, DB, Jack McArdle, DB, Rich Riotto, QB, Joe Stracci, LB.
1984: First Team: Ted Bell, K, C.R, Chernik, LB, Steve Gulakowski, DB, Mike John, QB, Jim Kraus, OT, Bill McClung, TE, A.J. Pagano, RB, Kevin Rozsa, DT. Second Team: Eugene Berkowitz, OT, John Savage, NG.
1983: First Team: Ed Kusko, OT.
1982: First Team: Ed Kusko, OT, Denny Strosko, RB, Jeff Virgin, LB.
1981: First Team: Pete Soom, P.
1980: First Team: Dan Doyle, DT, Max Regula, DB, Lance Mondock, DE, Mike Barbour, OT. Second Team: Frank Yoho, TE.
