2013: First Team: Kelsey Cunningham (SS), Stephanie Zur (2B). Second Team: Sadie Marak (3B), Emily Watson (UT). Honorable Mention: Krista McCartney (P)
2012: Second Team: Stephanie Zur (2B), Madison Rotto (DP)
2011: Second Team: Kelsey Cunningham (UT)
2010: Second Team: D.J. Ufolla (SS), Victoria Doerschner (3B)
2009: First Team: Valerie Schultz (1B). Second Team: Katelynn Falleroni (2B), Kelly Morrow (SS), Rebecca Nachreiner (P)
2008: First Team: Amanda Howard (OF), Rebecca Nachreiner (P), Hannah Schulz (C). Second Team: Tanesha Minney (IF), Valerie Schultz (IF)
2007: First Team: Stacey Bugle (IF), Amanda Howard (OF), Rebecca Nachreiner (P), Valerie Schultz (IF). Second Team: Hannah Schulz (C). Honorable Mention: Kelly Morrow (OF/IF)
2006: First Team: Rebecca Nachreiner (P), Stephanie Spisak (IF/OF) Second Team: Stacey Bugle (SS), Amanda Howard (OF), Hannah Schulz (C)
2005: First Team: Amanda Howard (OF), Melissa Metcalf (1B), Stephanie Spisak (3B). Second Team: Tanesha Minney (1B/3B), Stacye Bugle (SS). Honorable Mention: Caryn Becker (P/OF)
2004: First Team: Angela Iadanza (1B/OF), Lauren Pieri (P). Second Team: Stacey Bugle (SS/2B), Chelsea Gillen (SS/2B), Courtney Grubich (P/1B), Caryn Becker (P/OF)
2003: First Team: Melissa Witzberger (OF). Second Team: Lauren Pieri (P). Honorable Mention: Angela Iandanza (1B)
2002: First Team: Jill Miller (SS). Second Team: Angela Iadanza (IF/OF), Jill Shields (C/OF)
2001: First Team: Marlena Fox (OF), Jill Miller (SS). Honorable Mention: Trisha Olenik (3B), Angela Iadanza (IF/OF), Lauren Pieri (P), Dana Pecanis (P/OF)
2000: First Team: Jill Miller (SS). Second Team: Trisha Olenik (3B)
1999: Second Team: Kristen Flowers (OF), Trisha Olenik (3B), Colony Packroni (OF). Honorable Mention: Jill Miller (SS), Amy Kurowski (C), Tara Belcastro (1B/2B)
1998: First Team: Michelle Stano (P), April LeViere (C). Second Team: Colony Packroni (OF), Leslie Wiseman (OF). Honorable Mention: Melissa Bauer (SS), Trisha Olenik (3B)
1997: First Team: Michelle Stano (P). Second Team: April LeViere (C), Miki Flowers (OF), Coletta Schuler (SS). Honorable Mention: Colony Packroni (OF), Melissa Bauer (2B)
1996: First Team: Tricia Lander (SS), Michelle Stano (P), Michelle Ross (OF), April LeViere (C). Second Team: Steph Rowland (1B), Miki Flowers (OF)
1995: First Team: Tricia Lander (SS), Michelle Stano (P), Michelle Ross (OF). Second Team: Lynn LeViere (C), Steph Rowland (1B), Tracy Harris (3B)
1994: First Team: Tricia Lander (SS), Lynn LeViere (C). Second Team: Michelle Ross (OF). Honorable Mention: Lori Mays, Tracy Frank, Steph Rowland (1B)
1993: First Team: Jamie O'Donnell (SS), Yvette Brown (OF), Tricia Lander (SS). Second Team: Bobbi McCosky (3B). Honorable Mention: Rachel Halfhill (2B/C)
1992: First Team: Bobbi McCosky (3B), Jamie O'Donnell (SS). Second Team: Miriam Mavrich (OF), Kim Zubovic (OF)
1991: First Team: Bobbi McCosky (OF), Amy Rush (1B), Tina Zottola (P). Second Team: Jamie O'Donnell (3B), Renae Schmondiuk (2B). Honorable Mention: Tracey Doyle (P)
1990: First Team: Amy Rush (1B), Tracye Doyle (OF), Miriam Mavrich (OF), Angie Mavrich (SS). Second Team: Jamie O'Donnell (3B), Kymn Griffith (C)
1989: First Team: Amy Rush (1B), Lisa Graham (3B). Second Team: Nat Braddock (OF)
1988: First Team: Amy Rush (1B). Second Team: Nat Braddock (OF)