| Year | 1st | 2nd |
| 2008 | Jaclyn Joseph | Carrie Connelly |
| 2007 | Emily Hogan | Katie Orient |
| 2006 | Jennifer Springer | Anne Reynolds |
| 2005 | Lindsay Caniff | Samantha Malone |
| 2004 | Catherine Davis | Bethany Blackburn |
| 2003 | Michael McKito | Kaleen Spangler |
| 2002 | Lauren Shettler | Amanda Wasnik |
| 2001 | Michelle Babb | Erin Haseleu |
| 2000 | Jody Hoffman | Anne Simmermon |
| 1999 | Jaimee Heffner | Carrie Banaszek |
| 1998 | Ann Palker | Darrelle Zrimsek |
| 1997 | Jennifer Polly |
Katey Wetzler |
| 1996 | Thomas Shoup | Susan Hetrick |
| 1995 | Kelly Carroto | Jennifer Zamber |
| 1994 | Tanya Schmader | Coleen O'Leary |
| 1993 | Jennifer Kase | Fory Musser, IV |
| 1992 | Christopher Norris | Rita Pasko |
| 1991 | Kelly Verba | Dustin Howarth |
| 1990 | Allison Bruce | Sherry Burke |
| 1989 | Kristi Masick | Margaret Carnegie |
| 1988 | Gregory J. Zelinsky | Sherri Ann Aronhalt |
| 1987 | Valerie D. Weber | Tris-Ann Jodon |
| 1986 | Jennifer S. Mundorff | Steve H. Werner |
| 1985 | Lois G. Weltum | Martha S. Kyle |
| 1984 | Rhea L. Sprowls | Marie A. McKay |
| 1983 | Janet L. Mazurek | Anthony D. Bartirome |
| 1982 | Pamela A. Richie | James A. Hoko |