2011-12: Second Team: Zach Bellhy (G)
2010-11: Second Team: Brian Felker (G), Paul Matthews (G)
2009-10: Second Team: Brian Felker (G). Honorable Mention: Matt Drakeley (G), Paul Matthews (G), Albert Varacallo (G)
2008-09: First Team: Josip Lucic-Jozak (C), Wahab Owolabi (F). Honorable Mention: Brian Felker (G)
2007-08: First Team: Josip Lucic-Jozak (C). Second Team: Wahab Owolabi (F)
2006-07: First Team: Jon Koch (G), Brandon Studer (G). Honorable Mention: Wahab Owolabi
2005-06: First Team: Jon Koch (G). Second Team: Josip Lucic-Jozak (C). Honorable Mention: Brandon Studer (G)
2004-05: Second Team: Jon Koch (G). Honorable Mention: Brandon Studer (G)
2003-04: Second Team: Jon Koch. Honorable Mention: Steve Button (F), Brandon Studer (G)
2002-03: First Team: Nolan Larry (G). Honorable Mention: Steve Button (F), Michael Chicone (G/F)
2001-02: First Team: Nolan Larry (G). Honorable Mention: Scott Chodor (F), Tony Franz (C)
2000-01: Second Team: Nolan Larry (G)
1999-00: First Team: Nate Luderer (F). Second Team: Ian Versaw (C)
1998-99: Second Team: Eduardo Carrera (F)
1997-98: First Team: Ryan Brown (F). Second Team: Dave Spires (C)
1996-97: First Team: Ryan Brown (F)
1995-96: Second Team: Mark Murphy (G)
1994-95: First Team: Greg Colbert (G). Second Team: Mark Patrick (C)
1993-94: First Team: Terry Wilkins (C), Mark Johnson (F). Second Team: Matt Johnson (G), Kenyon Bonner (F). Honorable Mention: Greg Colbert (G).
1992-93: First Team: Terry Wilkins (C), Mark Johnson (F), Matt Johnson (G). Second Team: Kenyon Bonner (F). Honorable Mention: Jeff Petri (G)
1991-92: First Team: Terry Wilkins (C), Mark Johnson (F), Matt Johnson (G). Honorable Mention: Jeff Petri (G)
1990-91: First Team: Dave Branchen (C). Honorable Mention: Matt Johnson (G), Jeff Petri (G)
1989-90: First Team: Dave Branchen (C), Danny Jones (F). Honorable Mention: Rick Reid (G), Jeff Petri (G), Tim Sabram (G)
1988-89: First Team: Dave Branchen (C). Second Team: Danny Jones (F). Honorable Mention: Burt Stellers (G), Buddy Quertinmont (C)
1987-88: First Team: Danny Jones (F). Second Team: Dave Branchen (C). Honorable Mention: Andy Turzak (F)
1986-87: First Team: Andy Turzak (F). Second Team: Danny Jones (F)
1985-86: First Team: Alan Bradstock, Tony Torchia. Honorable Mention: Mike Potkul, Jeff Conn
1984-85: First Team: Tony Torchia (F). Second Team: Alan Bradstock, John Achille
1983-84: Second Team: Tony Torchia (F)
1982-83: First Team: Dan Colligan (C). Second Team: Tom Connolly (G)
1981-82: Second Team: Tom Connolly (G). Honorable Mention: Dan Colligan (C)
1980-81: Second Team: Dave Damico (G), Mike Pratt (G)
1979-80: Second Team: Dave Damico (G), Mike Pratt (G). Honorable Mention: Bob Yakovac (F)
1978-79: Second Team: Mike Pratt (G), Roger Raybuck (F)
1977-78: Second Team: Roger Raybuck (F)
1974-75: Jerry Rossi (G)
1972-73: Second Team: Mike Turkaly (F)
1971-72: Tom Ellis (F), Scott Herz (C)
1970-71: Tom Ellis (F), Scott Herz (C), Rich Relich (G)
1969-70: Terry Evans (G), Scott Herz (C)
1968-69: Terry Evans (G), Scott Herz (C)
1967-68: Terry Evans (G), Richard Orwig (F)
1966-67: Tom Marshall (C), Rick Orwig (F), Don Smith (G)
1965-66: Richard Bachansky (F)
1964-65: John Unice (G)
1963-64: Ed Cooper (C)
1962-63: Ed Cooper (C), Tobin Simon (G)